Originally made this for Liz's old AlertPay button thread but I really doubt she'd end up using it (I didn't really pay mind to where it says it has to be 'professional') -- might as well show it off here. Never really made any good GFX in my day but this time I'm actually pretty pleased with the result.
Alright, add the lines (You said you did already so that's not a big deal)
You need to have the wood grain going in a (counter)clockwise fashion, not how you have it now. Leave two (2) sides the same and then rotate the other two (2) sides at a right angle (90 degrees). The two sides you need to rotate need to be rotated in the opposite direction of each other so -90 degrees for one and 90 degrees for the other.