yes, compared to others on this forum. if 10 is best possible and 0 is a blank page, it's about 5. Mediocre at best, but definite improvement, and that it the real goal, because only if you improve faster than your peers will you become the best.
I just said I have that ammount of layers, so i could show people i am becoming more advanced
I actually agree with him, I normally don't rate because I reckon someone will get angry because I give them a 6 or 7 even though I think it's good. people give out 9's and 10's to easily here. 10 is supposed to be best of the best.
#2 has shitty rendering. 2/10 for given effort. #1 is minimalistic, and there is nothing whatsoever improvised, so thats a 3/10, again, for effort. Please, try harder. Learn to name layers, read tutorials on smudging, etc. Thank you.