Imma go for ethereal. It honestly seems like the best even though it's not much. It's simple, smooth, and it flows, which is more than can be said for the others.
My thoughts line-by-line:
Golden.: Not much to be said.
bsrkrnghivu: Same, just some training work.
Faux: Tiny and washed out, dislike the text. blurred bg's also not good.
Me: Man mine pops out and hits you in the eye lol. Way too many overlays, too high contrast. The mosaic was probably a bad idea. I need to work on my subtlety.
Scrcrw: Don't really care much personally for subtle photo-manips, and i'm hatin those black bars. It's creative and interesting though, and I would give it a high rating overall. I don't think it's enough for a winning sig though, more of a curiosity.
IMO, most of the voters here deserve a good pimp-slap for their circlejerking. We should probably go back to a poll, but allow posts if anyone wants to give a serious analysis.
Please select one of the following signatures to vote for. Please reply to this thread with your vote and a valid reason for choosing this person.
-Votes may not be accepted due to votes that fail to give valid reason.
-All posts that are not votes are subject to deletion.
@Golden.: The robot image isn't really high-quality...
@bsrkrnghivu: Very simple and cheap...
@Faux: Very good, don't like the left side, don't know why..
@Remorse: Too dark.. use higher resolution pictures next time
@Ethereal: I like the flow and the color, the robots mouth is well placed and like the eye glow
@Scrcrw: Like the pic because it kind of emphasizes the domination of the woman, don't know which part is edited though, borders acceptable, but too big
Last edited by Lucianberg; 05-14-2011 at 12:35 PM.