TBH now that I've had a second look at these I can honestly say that fechers has a bit more problems then i stated. However i voted originally on which one appealed to me most and at that time his did more than yours. Seeing it now I wouldn't really vote for either based on appeal because yours just doesn't seem right and his is kind of unplanned and LQ in a way and yea. Skill wise you beat him but I guess it's that first glance that means the most in some forms of art, mainly advertising. Idk,
Not changing my vote just simply stating whats going on.
I vote for Ethereal, Fecher's work is too low quality and too much shit going on in it. It's also too colorful. In th other hand, Jimmy's work has some unexplainable good aura in itself and the colours match almost perfectly. It's a nice execution, I like it.