Classing Masterclass [Class One]

[[MPGH]Doc]

Ali G
1. low inter.
it looks very clean and nicely done *
effects compliment each other.
2. high mod
Colors are a bit dull, i dont like them
Gwd pentooling.
3.Low novice
Too much empty space, bad text, bad blending, lighting needs work.
4.solid mod
imo again too much empty space, would look better if smart sharpened imo.
5.Solid novice.
left side of the sig is too empty.
lighting needs work.

Heath
#1 - Solid Semi Pro
#2 - Solid Semi Pro
#3 - High Novice/Low Moderate
#4 - High Semi Pro
#5 - Solid Novice

My thoughts:
1st one is amazing. Seems like the whole thing was made from pentool. Great color choice, text and creativity. Solid Semi Pro.

2nd one is amazing. It shows the true skills of a GFX designer. It has creativity and imagination in one bundle. The color choice is consistent. The only little concern I had was that there are 3 focals, but not a biggie, it would seem a little weird with only one.

3rd one is so-so. The smudging and lighting is great. The blending is good. The downside of this sig is what a person sees. The left and right side are plain. Even though he focused on the focal, the sig seems pretty boring.

4th one is my favorite. I like everything about it. The creativity and imagination. Even though the left and right side are a little plain, the focal has so much detail. This looks amazing, great job.

5th one is ok. The choice of stock isn't great and the choice of color is a little bit off. The lighting is decent, but the right side is too plain. Nothing but part of the stock is on the right side. Brushing seems plain. Overall, decent work.

Luffy
1. Low Inter
General overall appeal, great usage of syringes. Great flow.

2. High Mod
Great artwork, but composition needs work and the idea doesn't work

3. Solid Novice
The focal can't be seen very well, and too much negative space. The smudging could use work, but the text is fine.

4. Solid Mod
Great composition, great feel and idea, but too dark.

5. Low Novice
Render is lq, background doesn't match, too many effects that cover the focal, no lighting, no flow.

Ryan
1 High mod - Low inter
2 Solid inter
3 Solid - High nov
4 Semi-pro
5 High nov - low mod

[Scrcrw]

mine were more accurate but i told doc on msn
ryan was next closest

[Brizingir]

by his latest do u mean the abstract pentool

coooorrreeect

[Scrcrw]

coooorrreeect

and thats better than my typos and captain america
um ok then

[Matt]

mine were more accurate but i told doc on msn
ryan was next closest

Correction, I got 4/5.

[Scrcrw]

Correction, I got 4/5.

u got 4/5 wrong
Shaynes
High inter
High inter/Low semi
Solid Nov
Semi
High nov

Mine
High inter
Solid inter
Solid nov
Semi
Low mod

Urs
Low inter
High Mod
Solid Nov
Solid Mod
Low nov

[Matt]

u got 4/5 wrong
Shaynes
High inter
High inter/Low semi
Solid Nov
Semi
High nov

Mine
High inter
Solid inter
Solid nov
Semi
Low mod

Urs
Low inter
High Mod
Solid Nov
Solid Mod
Low nov

I meant 4/5 of Kyle's rankings.

[Scrcrw]

mmmmm
i still agree wid doc on 4
its obviously semi to me, great c4d
but i found the lp aswell

[kikikannibal]

I was the closest obv /

[Matt]

Who do ya trust more, doc, well it was a good ranking, but I needed Kyle's. Kyle's a ranker man... oh well. Doc, is it time for the second one?

[Scrcrw]

i trust docs ranking as miuch as kyles
both have good knowledge even though kyle is a classer rankings are still opinions

[Matt]

Well that means doc's rankings are as much as an opinion as Kyles. But, if you consider Kyle's rankings equal to doc's, how would my rankings be 4/5 "wrong"?

[Scrcrw]

no no no no
not equal in that sense
like equal in the sense in that they both know wat they are doing and are cappable of producing accurate rankings

[Matt]

no no no no
not equal in that sense
like equal in the sense in that they both know wat they are doing and are cappable of producing accurate rankings

Yes yes, I meant equal in the sense that they are good classers. But, if they both know what their doing *equally great* how would my rankings be 4/5 wrong?

[Scrcrw]

Yes yes, I meant equal in the sense that they are good classers. But, if they both know what their doing *equally great* how would my rankings be 4/5 wrong?

going off docs rankings for these tags u only got 1 right