To be honest, yes it was. You just had some mismatched colors as a gradient and brushed splatter and added a render on top of it. It lacked depth, lighting and flow. Basically those are the 3 biggest requirements to a good signature. This one looks like a black background with color mismatched fractals in the background a big render a smaller render with low opacity and some text with halo font.
https://www.mpgh.net/forum/40-photosh...aking-56k.html
Not to be rude but, read this tutorial. You can benefit a lot from it.