Well i guess i said that, if you take my logic and go further, by cause/effect, he would have.
-But you would have to take into account that it would be by eventual effect. It wouldn't just be god going "FIRST CELL EXIST!!!" and it miraculously did.(using the logic i provided)
First cell always existed? What if i always existed? What if?? WHAT IF??
-No real argument there. I mean what if it always existed? Kinda like saying the first cell was the start of everything, when even the "big bang theory" proved this wrong.
-What if I always existed? I dunno, don't really bother with such absurd logic.
"By saying that it's possible for God to always have existed, you are saying that anything could have always existed. "
How does that work? How does "god always exist" equal "anything can always exist". ?_? I mean its not even on a logical reasoning using any logic. You take two seperate ideas and say they relate.
Wouldn't 13billion years ago mean nothing to theist if he is timeless?