I have continued this debate to a new post because that would have been a huge bump and i like being a member of MPGH so i just started a new thread.
I have used one link for the purposes of statistics, and by no way mean to advertize or anything like that.
Alright everybody. First things first, introductions. I am 17 years old. I am in the Junior to Senior summer in high school. I am in the top 20 of my class in a class of over 700. I am in my 4th year of debate, as in the class. I am American. Before going on i would like to state that American cannot be defined for the simple fact that no 2 Americans are alike, much like any other country on this planet. We all have different sensibilities. Different thoughts and hopes and opinions. So to say "those Americans" or "those British" or "those Japanese" is out right ignorant and vulgar.
Now, onto the question. The question that seems to have been lost in this forum is whether or not the U.S.'s bombing of Japan was justified. Before i begin, there is no yes or no answer and this debate can never be answered in such a way as that. The answer to this question boils down to two things. 1. The value you place on a Human life. 2. Nationalism. Combined these two values make a question. How much do you value life and do you value your countries lives over any other countries? As an American, I believe it is easy to value American lives over any other country. I believe that you feel the same way about your country. So here is the answer to the question in a purely philosophical standpoint. If you are American, yes the bombing of Japan was completely justified because it saved AMERICAN lives. If you are any other nationality, you have mixed feelings. If you are Japanese, no because it cost about 135,000 ( https://www.atomicarchive.com/Docs/MED/med_chp10.shtml) Japanese lives.
Now, if you want the answer based on facts, that i will not give because that would take an entire book to state and I've already typed A LOT. Do the research for yourself if you want that answer.
[/SIZE]