Need Constructive Criticism on Photoshop

[.Supreme]

Just quickly put a friends face over this pic, he requested it from me.

Also requested for it to be 3D anaglyph

Anything I did wrong/could improve?

BEFORE: i.imgur.com/gWg0lM8.jpg

AFTER: i.imgur.com/0u4JiIm.png

[Predator]

Get out Swag Fag.

[.Supreme]

Get out Swag Fag.

Neither of the guys are me, and my friend is somewhat of a Swag fag

[Horror]

[IMG] tag pls, too lazy to C/P.

[CrossCombat3]

I Think the point of photoshop is to make the picture change but not look changed, a dog can recognize that's photoshopped

[bowlcut]

It's mediocre at best.
The fact sticks out way too much, and it's completely linear (flat).
Add some depth, change it up a bit. The red/blue blur is a little neat, but nothing special.
It's okay, but it's not good.
Oh and let's get a chink to look at it.
@Doc

[.Supreme]

image tag pls, too lazy to C/P.

Don't have the sufficient number of posts to do that, can one of you two do it for me?

[bowlcut]

Don't have the sufficient number of posts to do that, can one of you two do it for me?

Hold up a second.

BEFORE:


AFTER:

[.Supreme]

I Think the point of photoshop is to make the picture change but not look changed, a dog can recognize that's photoshopped

I think the point of this thread was to get CONSTRUCTIVE criticism, not to bag on my Beginner PS skills.

[Blake]

The after picture kinda fucked with my eyes. I honestly think you did a horrible job.

Were you going for a face swap type of image or just his head on that guys body? If it's the 2nd one then okay, that's simple but why the weird effect or colors on over it?

[.Supreme]

It's mediocre at best.
The fact sticks out way too much, and it's completely linear (flat).
Add some depth, change it up a bit. The red/blue blur is a little neat, but nothing special.
It's okay, but it's not good.
Oh and let's get a chink to look at it.
@Doc

Yeah, I'm pretty beginner at GFX, and I did the 3D anaglyph following a tutorial on YouTube step-by-step

I also did this in 2-3 Minutes MAX, so expect it to be a little sloppy

---------- Post added at 04:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:41 PM ----------

The after picture kinda fucked with my eyes. I honestly think you did a horrible job.

Were you going for a face swap type of image or just his head on that guys body? If it's the 2nd one then okay, that's simple but why the weird effect or colors on over it?

Isn't the underlined part the same thing? The "Weird Effect" was supposed to have a 3D (without the glasses) Feel to it, I know I'm horrible at PS

[bowlcut]

Yeah, I'm pretty beginner at GFX, and I did the 3D anaglyph following a tutorial on YouTube step-by-step

I also did this in 2-3 Minutes MAX, so expect it to be a little sloppy

Well for a tiny project it's okay. At least you're honest with the "I'm new" thing. Most people would try to defend their shit.

[.Supreme]

Well for a tiny project it's okay. At least you're honest with the "I'm new" thing. Most people would try to defend their shit.

No, like I'm seriously NEW at this. Just downloaded photoshop yesterday to be honest

[Oneirish]

All it takes is practice. If I were you, I'd avoid using people to start off with and start with basic tutorials for landscapes, effects, etc. Then you can incorporate it into a photo of someone. The 3-D effect on this is pretty sloppy and what did you do with the face, swap it?

[.Supreme]

All it takes is practice. If I were you, I'd avoid using people to start off with and start with basic tutorials for landscapes, effects, etc. Then you can incorporate it into a photo of someone. The 3-D effect on this is pretty sloppy and what did you do with the face, swap it?

Yeah but it was hard as hell, his face had different color tone (greyish), and had different lighting, not to mention, the Original Picture is in HD, meanwhile, his face is pixelated.. It was a tedious job