Originally Posted by
Empire
So with the movie coming out, I thought I'd make a post on it.
Noah, like most Old Testament stories, has 3 major flaws: Moral, Inconsistency within the bible, and Inconsistency within what we know.
1. Morals.
The moral of Noah is pretty much what most of the Old Testament teaches. Be god's chosen ones or you are fucked. I'd like to argue there is a lesson to "listening and obeying god" but there isn't any mention that God attempted to speak to anyone but Noah. Not only that, God would consider children, unborn children, and everyone else irredeemable. Which doesn't make any sense.
2. Inconsistency within the bible.
-God smites people if they are bad. He did it in Sodom and Gomorah, he did it actually quite a few times. So it's odd that instead of just killing them straight off he needed a flood, to make all the animals get in a boat, and to make this guy Noah spend 40 years for what god does instantly in other scenarios. Not only that, since Sodom and Gomorah came after, this type of "wipe all the evil off" clearly doesn't work.
3. Inconsistency within what we know
Wooden boat wouldn't have been able to hold 2 of every species that would have been wiped out.
Noah's bloodline would be the start of mankind from that gap, genealogy tells us differently.
Worldwide flooding would erase a lot of species that can only live in certain conditions, not on a boat(i.e. freshwater fish, insects, etc. etc.).
Wooden boat would also not be able to survive the initial impact of the flood. First rock it hit would destroy the ark entirely, if not from the impact of the water alone.
Inbreeding doesn't work.
Ecosystem problems:
A. If the water was as high as the mountain(which it said it was) then the temperature would be too cold for most of the animals and Noah himself.
B. Water pressure/water mixture.
C. Food after the flood. Herbivores would have no food and if carnivores ate anything they'd wipe out a whole species.
So anyone want to argue on the side that The Flood was real?
Edit: Sorry, also wanted to add that on Ecosystem-A certain animals would die even if the situation was normal. Some animals can flat out not survive outside of their habitat.