If you don't mind, could you maybe be a bit more detailed with your rating? to take 4 points off of a sig just because you don't like a certain style seems a bit rushed in judgement. Maybe explain the other things that need work? People really won't get any better at gfx if you rate things that simply. I understand you can do whatever you want, and say whatever. It's just more of a request, since I'm new at gfx and can use some crit with something more constructive than that.
Okay, The C4d's are to much and the red and white spallers at the top doesnt match, the render looks too choppy and looks like all you did was lower the opacity, i dont like that fire thing that goes through him it justs neglects the renders image. Also I hate popouts. But still i could see where you where going with this. Better reply now?
Heheh, much better. Actually I didn't touch the opacity on the render. It was sharpened and than faded to darken, lightly erased at the hardlines, burned at the edges, than dodged at focal points. I totally agree with you about the red and white spatter, I should have used render colors for that. As far as the fire that goes through the render, thats actually part of the render, I was gonna dupe, than decided to make it look like a flaming arrow rushing by him to explode into the c4d. Honestly this isn't one of my better sigs, I just wanted to try something a bit different. Thanks for the crit, I really appreciate that.