well if you were going out with me and i said surprise me, i would like a scary movie or a comedy. usually something mildly scary not frightening scary. something that will make her want to cuddle with you. i say bring both horror and comedy and let her pick.
If she hasn't seen it already, Jennifer's Body.
Its kinda gory but not scary so you will be cool as Keith Stone but she will be jumping at every scene, and Megan Fox is going to turn her on and make your job that much easier.
SuperBadassExtraordinaire says (5:53 PM):
babysitting is ghey
Corndog says (5:53 PM):
Baron De Montesquieu..Wtf? [Czar] says (5:53 PM):
you're a breaded hotdog