We'd just get somebody that doesn't have shit taste to recommend anime. Like Empire or something, everything he's recommended me I've enjoyed. The recommendations would be the first post, and I suppose people could post and mention a GM or something to edit the post. This section is already dead, hidden in the back of a shitty subforum called Entertainment.
Depends on the subforum you visit really, current events tend to have the most like-minded fans. You should try finding members and adding them, I mostly talk to friends I made in the forum via profile comments nowadays. But overall MAL pretty much shits on anybody that likes SAO. CR is probably the worst anime forum I've been to... AnimeSuki is a decent forum.
I'll check them out then.
For the reviews, I really have no say, but I wouldn't mind it.