Well first off look at all the numbers.
You noticed how there is only one 19 and 18 so rule out those months.
Albert couldn't be told Aug because he wouldn't know exactly what date it is.
Since he got the Birthday from knowing the day from Bernard.
The only likely answer could be July 16.
____________________________
Need help? Pm me
___________________________
Please Press The Thanks If I Helped
There are only two dates with unique numbers: May 19 or June 18. If Bernard was given a date of either 18 or 19, he'd know right away. The fact that Albert says Bernard doesn't know means the month he was given wasn't May or June. Bernard has now figured this much out, and if he had been told 14 he wouldn't know the answer as there are still two 14s left (July and August) leaving July 16, August 15 and August 17. Bernard must've been given the number 16, because for Albert to say he knows too would rule out August, which still has two remaining dates. That leaves the answer: July 16.
See, if you look at the dates, you'll notice that May 19 and June 18 stand out.
After further analyzing the paper, you can see that Bernard realizes one thing.
Bernard realizes that you're a ******.
Therefore, you are, indeed, a ******.
Hunter Jr. (10-16-2015)
im too stupid to figure this out hahaha