Ali G vs Ethereal vs Keroaplt

[Ali G]

Ali G




Ethereal

[img]https://i597.photobucke*****m/albums/tt55/Domesplitter/3wayz.png[/img]


Keroaplt

[img]https://i1114.photobucke*****m/albums/k538/ImminentJM/ethaligbattle-1.png[/img]

[Mr.Seyeko]

I can honestly say i dont like any of em o.O

@Ali G
At first glance it was cool then second one, i saw alot of mistakes and its sorta flat, and the random c4d doesn't help with depth at all. Especially in bottom right, takes attention away from the focal.
and the splatter thats going straight through the tag takes away from any flow at all, that it could of had. Lighting seems way off also. The blending is lacking as well, dont realy get whats goin on in the tag..

@Ethereal
This one is okay.. but i have seen better from you, i like the colors and flow and all that but i dont think the render quit fits the theme and its a little small also, There's no actual blending or lighting, i think if you picked a better focal this would of turned out pretty cool.

@Keroaplt
The only problem i see with this one is over blending and smudging, can barely make out the focal, but i love the smudge effects, Lighting needs work and basically thats all i can say about this one.. you did pretty well out of the 3

I voted for Keroaplt.

[Venom]

@Ali G

how do you do that think in the warriors left arm?

[Ali G]

I can honestly say i dont like any of em o.O

@Ali G
At first glance it was cool then second one, i saw alot of mistakes and its sorta flat, and the random c4d doesn't help with depth at all. Especially in bottom right, takes attention away from the focal.
and the splatter thats going straight through the tag takes away from any flow at all, that it could of had. Lighting seems way off also. The blending is lacking as well, dont realy get whats goin on in the tag..

@Ethereal
This one is okay.. but i have seen better from you, i like the colors and flow and all that but i dont think the render quit fits the theme and its a little small also, There's no actual blending or lighting, i think if you picked a better focal this would of turned out pretty cool.

@Keroaplt
The only problem i see with this one is over blending and smudging, can barely make out the focal, but i love the smudge effects, Lighting needs work and basically thats all i can say about this one.. you did pretty well out of the 3

I voted for Keroaplt.

its like.. u took the most un professional tag and said its the best.


I mean, u should have said Bawls has the best tag.. not keroaplt.. nothing personal dude, but its flat, no good blending and stuff, still KIU
IT is ur opinion, so ill let it be, i wont argue with u, tnx for voting

@Ali G

how do you do that think in the warriors left arm?

what do u mean exactly?

[ARHQA$Y$YW4AYG4y]

It wasn't really a hard choice.

I vote for Ali G because Keroaplt's work is really bad compared to the other two. Jimmy did an even worse job on choosing the appropriate render with that illustration, and I know he can do better. Ali G's work, on the other hand, looks good on the first look, but has some blending issues and a fail at depth attemt.

@Ali G

how do you do that think in the warriors left arm?

It's called C4D render.

[Venom]

its like.. u took the most un professional tag and said its the best.


I mean, u should have said Bawls has the best tag.. not keroaplt.. nothing personal dude, but its flat, no good blending and stuff, still KIU
IT is ur opinion, so ill let it be, i wont argue with u, tnx for voting



what do u mean exactly?

chuck i know -.-

@Ali G

it looks like the c4d is fusioning with the arm

how to make it so reallistic??

[ShadeyZzZz]

chuck i know -.-

@Ali G

it looks like the c4d is fusioning with the arm

how to make it so reallistic??

soft brushes + overlay i guess?

[Venom]

how do i use soft brushes?

[Music]

how do i use soft brushes?

just go look up tutorials

[ARHQA$Y$YW4AYG4y]

Now he gonna ask how to read tutorials.

[Venom]

LOL

come on Chuck

im learning

that's why i dont know much

no need to make fun of me -.-

[Scrcrw]

jimmy
it's fresh, new and creative
and martin has too much random blurring

[Parade]

Ali G or Eth... I'm going with Eth.

[[MPGH]Ethereal]

I can honestly say i dont like any of em o.O

@Ali G
At first glance it was cool then second one, i saw alot of mistakes and its sorta flat, and the random c4d doesn't help with depth at all. Especially in bottom right, takes attention away from the focal.
and the splatter thats going straight through the tag takes away from any flow at all, that it could of had. Lighting seems way off also. The blending is lacking as well, dont realy get whats goin on in the tag..

@Ethereal
This one is okay.. but i have seen better from you, i like the colors and flow and all that but i dont think the render quit fits the theme and its a little small also, There's no actual blending or lighting, i think if you picked a better focal this would of turned out pretty cool.

@Keroaplt
The only problem i see with this one is over blending and smudging, can barely make out the focal, but i love the smudge effects, Lighting needs work and basically thats all i can say about this one.. you did pretty well out of the 3

I voted for Keroaplt.

You seriously chose the worst tag out of the bunch..
which makes that whole long drawn stuff you wrote look dumb...
Nothing against Kero, but he chose the crappiest render..and the whole thing just isn't up to his standards.
Lulz Ali YU votin for me nigga.

Anyway not making excuses here, but I found it incredibly hard to find any kind of motivation with these renders..I chose the one I used because I figured no one else would use it.

[Keroaplt]

I have standards now? Dafuck?
I was gonna scrap it and start over but I was rushed on time

If I was gonna vote I would say Ali g because holy shit that atmo
But then again neither or the tags really caught my eye
They all had problems

This didnt turn out well


I blame whoever chose the renders