I don't understand

[Ed]

Why my posts in this thread got deleted
https://www.mpgh.net/forum/335-minecr...ns-thread.html
They were on topic and this this post doesn't get deleted
https://www.mpgh.net/forum/335-minecr...ml#post5672456

@Woods
@Paladin
@iMexi
@Disturbed is there a reason listed?

The thread is about ideas for the next Minecraft Competition. Physcadelic posted an Idea about houses, woods said it would be too easy so I pointed out how it wouldn't be easy.
He then admits that Pools are part of the house but slides are not. I asked him why and now my posts after that got deleted

[crex]

Your posts and my posts arguing about that is not on topic. It's to DISCUSS or SUGGEST them. Not to argue. Which is why I deleted them because they were not meeting the requirements. And FYI, a pool and slide is NOT part of a freaking house.

[Moto]

Discussion = discussing the topic. From what it looks like, Ed WAS discussing the topic.

[crex]

Discussion = discussing the topic. From what it looks like, Ed WAS discussing the topic.

Arguing about whether slides and pools are part of a house is REALLY discussing to you? It has nothing to do with minecraft.

[Ed]

Your posts and my posts arguing about that is not on topic. It's to DISCUSS or SUGGEST them. Not to argue. Which is why I deleted them because they were not meeting the requirements. And FYI, a pool and slide is NOT part of a freaking house.

and again, i'll use my example
If you're buying a house and It has a pool in the garden, you're not expecting to get the pool as well?

clearly I was discussing how the House could be more complex than you think.

[crex]

and again, i'll use my example
If you're buying a house and It has a pool in the garden, you're not expecting to get the pool as well?

clearly I was discussing how the House could be more complex than you think.

Yes but after 6 posts it's not really discussing about minecraft anymore.

[Paladin]

Actually I think @Ed is right, he was talking about things for Physc's idea, which is a valid discussion.

[Ed]

Yes but after 6 posts it's not really discussing about minecraft anymore.

It doesn't have to be about minecraft, it just has to be about the topic of discussion. Which in this case was how can regular houses be made more complicated and challenging to build.

[Polo]

I agree, my post also got edited for no reason? lulwat.

OFFTOPIC: If you have a garden/a pool in your backyard, HOW IS NOT APART OF THE HOUSE?!

SERIOUSLY YOO

[Paladin]

Undeleting posts, @Ed/@Polo

Link me to possible discussion-valid posts.

[Polo]

Undeleting posts, @Ed/@Polo

Link me to possible discussion-valid posts.

Thank you, .

[Paladin]

Thank you, .

Your post was edited?

[Ed]

Undeleting posts, @Ed/@Polo

Link me to possible discussion-valid posts.

was there a reason listed for why they were deleted?

https://www.mpgh.net/forum/335-minecr...ml#post5668998

[Paladin]

"Offtopic over and over and over."

[Ed]

How is that offtopic though?