Originally Posted by
SpaWn
Change it to a tournament format with strict judges no public vote.
Simple as, and easy to enforce. Just make sure the judges know how to criticise pieces, and how to judge them.
Adds a bit more competition, and it can just be a tournament that stretches over a month, and then starts again the next month. Gives people more incentive to do better, rather then saying i'll just try again next week.