Subbed seems to be the preface for being an actual weeb, but if you enjoy being able to understand and not constantly read subtitles you can either: watched dubbed, or learn Japanese.
For the recommendations:
Parasyte the maxim is probably my favorite anime of all time, I believe you'd enjoy it.
Death Parade could be a good one for you.
Ajin isn't a bad pick.
Erased is pretty dark.
Tokyo Ghoul is a classic.
Psycho Pass would be a good one as well.
That's all I can think of off the top of my head. Cheers, good luck!