My Latest Siggy. plz rate

i like the pic, it looks like its been done in pencil.

Yeah. I agree with Chrono. the Text doesn't fit the color/style of the sig, and the Render needs blended. It is a little too big for my tastes. I'd give it a 4.5/10. The render is pretty cool. I like the sketch-y look.

the carpet/sketch look is not my taste and the text is just basic and blatantly sticks ouit, and the background its a bit fuzzy and grainy, with the render and background and text not belnding at all. it looks ok and has a nice looking background but overall its in need of more refined touches like blending and a border, and better fonts/text. needs work, 4.5/10

It looks like he modified the image on purpose to give that effect.

yes i noe he did but it just makes it stick out and detract from the sigs 'flow'. and colours are off so they dont contrast

yea i know the image is sketchy, it looked cool to me but u may have other tastes i guess.

The biggest difference to me, is that it has a sort of 3D look, he sorta stands out. :\

Good in a way, but not really good for a forum, IMO.