Tell me if this is a good sig or not.

Yeah, the second one was the "grunge" style...
What can I improve on?
I used the tut on sigtutorials.com called basic grunge sigs.

deviantART: where ART meets application! great tuts

Well, thanks, is the 2nd one good for my 1st real sig, the first one is someone elses backround cause I didn't know how to make one.
Should I make it a lil bit bigger.
So it's clearer?

When I first sparked interest in the graphical fields.
I started looking into beginner tutorials, which bored me extremely.

I then started viewing almost pro level tutorials, might not of understood 100% of it, but it helped me way more than some beginner tutorial.

You should try the same.
Another site with great tutorials is planetrenders, join their forums.
Tough critic but it's for the best.

Good luck!

I really aprieciate(don't know how to spell it) your comments, I want you to be a critic, it helps me inprove massively.

normal sig size for MPGH is round 400x150 if it helps.

No problem.
You can always PM if you want some advice or some critique.

Nevermind, it must have just been like that for some reason it works now.

what program are you using?

I don't know why people steer towards such big siggy sizes.
I prefer around a 350x110.

It gives you a small amount of space to fill, therefore it's more eye appeasing.
With a larger signature, it leaves you more space to fill.

Therefore, 'greatening' your chance for mistake or the viewer just gets bored of it.

i dk why, i hate smaller sigs...id prefer bigger with more to say...you know?

Yeah, I edited it cause I didn't want to double post, but it works, it must have just done that because I just dled it.
I would like bigger sigs more, more space for your work, I agree.
I was using PS3 but it stopped working, so i'm using PS2 and I love it.

I guess you will learn through time.