SOTW #3 Voting Thread

Please vote for one of the following pieces. Please also supply a reason with your vote.

All posts that are not votes or do not relate to the thread will be subject for deletion.

Ethereal:
[IMG]http://i597.photobucke*****m/albums/tt55/Domesplitter/Sotwfalling.png[/IMG]

Acinonyx:

Unknown-C:
[img]http://i1236.photobucke*****m/albums/ff448/Devougn/SOTW1-2.jpg[/img]

Wild Bill HickCock:
[img]http://i381.photobucke*****m/albums/oo259/darkstar9540/gravity.png[/img]

Keroaplt:
[img]http://i1114.photobucke*****m/albums/k538/ImminentJM/gravity.jpg[/img]

Ethereal: 1

Great depth
epic text
fits the theme really wel

good luck to all

Ethereal: 2

Just perfectly fits with the theme and has great execution.

Ethereal : 3

Very abstract and original. I love it.

Ethereal : 4

i was told im not allowed to repeat other peoples posts...

Etheral 4
Keroaplt 1: Because i like the look of it, i know Ethereals is better in depth and alot more factors but its just not as pleasing to the eye. good luck all

eth - 5 no competition

eth - 6
Best of em all

Back to Keroaplt, render fits the background well

Originally Posted by Remorse

Hello new gfxer, let me inform you that "pleasing to the eye" is actually considered a bad thing in the current gfx section. Sounds counterintuitive, but art works in mysterious ways. Modern art is in right now, and if you like actual art, then you'll have to wait until the next gfx team.

No combo-breaking!

When did "pleasing to the eye" get retarded? It's only stupid when you can't back it up. Like,
"That's pleasing to the eye."
Compared to:
"That's pleasing to the eye because of how the colors mesh together and how the C4D's compliment the render while the background keeps it grungy enough to be a dark themed piece."

Originally Posted by Remorse

Sorry, but I'm a bit pissed at the state of this section after my one-year hiatus. I come back, and BAM badly-placed c4ds and text, ugly backgrounds, and gay rainbow sparklies are just fabulous!

Sorry, but I'm a bit pissed considering you were on a one-year hiatus. You believe that everything's going to stay the same as how you left it? Check all the olden arts, like Picasso, Van Gogh, Di Vinci. Are they crappy because it's outdated? Things evolve into newer types of art. Get with the program or get the hell out. If you think your way is better, then make your own art. We're glad to take it without your ******ry.

Originally Posted by Remorse

Got one problem with that: beginner. Arrogant, don't know my place, yeah. I enjoy letting my opinion be known, the stronger the better. And modern art is pretty much my biggest pet peeve, so I look forward to some confrontations.

There's a difference between wanting your opinion heard, and being rude. If you hate modern art, then go back to the cave you live in. Don't follow the trend, get small pox and die from it because anything modern (like medicine) is retarded.

Originally Posted by Remorse

And you call me arrogant.

You type this comment as if it states that you aren't arrogant. You still are.
He isn't arrogant. He's stating the truth.

AT THE END OF MY RANT:
Ethereal - 7
It's got perspective and depth, and nice complimenting colours. The only thing I dislike is the lighting :P

Jesus Christ...can we not have one Sotw voting thread where kids aren't arguing..?

and @Keroaplt
I'm glad you think that all I do in the gfx section is start trouble.

Not start trouble but resolve trouble
Anyway I may or may not be able to vote but
Ethereal-8
The depth in the piece got me a long with the vibrant colors

If i'm allowed to vote:
Ethereal: 9.
Putting aside my dislike for sparklies and rainbow colors, it flows the best and is the best thought-out and put together. I also like the effect on the hand reaching for the L, like a spot of realism in a fantasy. The depth though, feels off to me due to mixed signals from the background and the c4d's, along with the blending on her elbow.
The thing in the bottom left corner does give an interesting effect though, like the girl-thing and the debris in the top right had been shot out of a cannon.

I like U-C's because of the bold colors and warping effects, but it doesn't come together in the end, having no coherent focus.
Acinonyx's and Kero's are just c4d's on a bg with an equation and render, nothing more. Not particularly interesting or artistic.
Mine's just a couple effects and text on a black bg, so not even as interesting as the 2 above.

And Matt - it ain't over

I have too big an ego.

WHAT THE FUCK DID I MISS

Originally Posted by Dr. Vegas

WHAT THE FUCK DID I MISS

I hated on your/scrcw's/eth's collective art style (rainbow sparklies argh), and ryan argued with me. A lot. And it got justly deleted, except for matt's post. It was fun! join in next time!

SOTW #3 Voting Thread

Post a Reply

Tags for this Thread