How to Properly Rate Work.

I have been seeing some really stupid comments on Artwork presented to people
so, I decided to make a "suggestion" post to correct people on how to "properly" post a comment on artwork

-Well, you can start of by asking yourself these questions and answering them in proper post

• What do I think about this artwork? Do I like it? Why or why not?
  
• Try answering such as... Is the artwork is very "nice" because???
  
• How is the artwork setup???? things like Focus on the render, environment its set in, the lighting in the background etc...
  
• how are the elements of line, shape, form, texture, space and value used? How is basic patterns, variety of colors, balance of color schemes, emphasis, proportion is used in the sig over all..
  
• Try to understand the feeling or emotions of the artwork. What is the artist is trying to say?
  
• What do I think about this artwork? Do I like it? Why or why not?
  
• Was the artist successful in achieving the feeling they where trying to get across to the viewer?
  
• Is the finished product made by the artist is realistic or something that you can relate to? or is it just crappy mesh of abstract shapes thrown together with no prior thought to it

For a more detailed version, click this...
http://www.mpgh.net/forum/148-signat...iving_cnc.html

stickied .

Thank you Gourav, now people won't be like that to my GFX anymore. :]

Fantastic advice, thanks Gourav :-)

this was needed and necessary
thanks gourav

I feel bad. I told someone there art sucked and that it was gay.

finaly i know what a c4d is god i google it an it came up with shit plus this was not reaaly needed for people who can explain y the art work sucks e.g all of us who posted on this