SOTW #4 Voting Thread.

[[MPGH]Doc]

Sorry for being late on this guys. Hella busy after work the past week.

As usual vote for the one you believe to be the best looking. If you vote for yourself your vote will be discounted. f you ask for votes or beg for votes you will be disqualified. You must have at least 25 posts for the vote to count.

Really good turn out this week considering we had no advertising. Shows that people are becoming more aware of SOTW.

Edit: Just realised I cocked up the poll.
@Liz @Dave84311

Could one of you change the third last option from https://i.imgur.com/JuGRd.png to https://i.imgur.com/wNesk.png

Cheers in advance.

[[MPGH]Time]

Voted for the fourth .

[debbe]

@Doc you made a mistake I think, the 10th isnt mine, its ethereal's. I only qouted his post because i liked it, after the qoute I went Ontopic by placing my work:

Take a look at my post: https://www.mpgh.net/forum/380-challe...ry-thread.html

I hope I informed you well.

[swadoz]

I won't vote in the pool because you've made a mistake and I'm not blaming you for that, shit happens sometimes the only think I'm asking you to do is that you count the votes from this posts too since there is a missing tag

Obviously I vote for the missing tag which is:



PROS:

• The placement of every elements in this tag are just perfect
• the typo is well, it blends well with the C4D and with the overall color of the tag itself
• the light source is not forced, giving a neat color to the tag
• there's a good depth in the tag and we can see that in the corners perfectly

CONS:

• The sparkles at the gun are not necessary at all IMO, but thats just my opinion ofc, other then that this tag is perfect

About the other Entries:

#2 is not even a tag
#3 looks like a photo manipulation

both 2&3 entries are over sized tbh. this exceed the tag's limit.

GL & HF

SIDE NOTE:

I've a suggestion to become the contest fairly, Instead of letting everyone knows who is who keep the entrants anonymous, this will prevent cheating, friends will vote for their friend's tag, If someone is suspicious from asking for votes, disqualify that entrant

[Ryan]

Some really good entries this week...

[Da Kurlzz]

About the other Entries:

#2 is not even a tag
#3 looks like a photo manipulation

both 2&3 entries are over sized tbh. this exceed the tag's limit.

maybe i exceeded the limit by 5 pixels.

how does it not look like a tag though?

[[MPGH]Liz]

Is it fixed? @Doc if not, what needs fixing?

[DawgiiStylz]

Good luck to the competitors. Looks like i'm in first

[Ryan]

Is it fixed? @Doc if not, what needs fixing?

4 and 10 are the same.

[[MPGH]Liz]

Removed option 10 bc it had 0 votes, left 4 with 1 vote.

[Jacket]

Removed option 10 bc it had 0 votes, left 4 with 1 vote.

This tag needs to be added,https://i.imgur.com/wNesk.png. That should be all I think. Thanks again Liz.

[[MPGH]Liz]

Added .

[Black Eyed Peas]

Hard choice between #4 and #9, but I went with #4 after all.
Some very good pieces on this SOTW.

[[MPGH]Doc]

Is it fixed? @Doc if not, what needs fixing?

It's fixed. Thanks
@debbe Yeah I cocked up, sorry bout that. You had a good entry too. If you come close but don't win feel free to enter it into the next comp. Sorry bout that :P

I've a suggestion to become the contest fairly, Instead of letting everyone knows who is who keep the entrants anonymous, this will prevent cheating, friends will vote for their friend's tag, If someone is suspicious from asking for votes, disqualify that entrant

We've tried that many times before, and it just doesn't work well. For starters most of the people here recognise each others styles. Secondly the more activity a thread has the more likely someone will visit it, thus improving competition turn out. Right now it's easy to see if people are cheating. And people who are popular in this section know not to vote just because of friendship. If it were the case everyone would vote for Eth or Jacket. Right now it's been fairer than it has ever been, and I'm quite happy with it. Plus it gives people a chance to suss out the competition and to strive to make better tags and it gives me time to check up on any possible rips.

[swadoz]

maybe i exceeded the limit by 5 pixels.

how does it not look like a tag though?

both 2 and 3 looks like photo-manipulations, both are way too over-sized, there's no typo, I just don't see them as tags, thats all