SOTW #48 Vote thread

Posts 110 of 10 · Page 1 of 1
SOTW #48 Vote thread
Only team members vote
use the format

420Sabotuer:

EnergyK:

Rick93

Flash

Molina174:

daniliard:

Heath:

ginaaahx3:

BSG.Flash:

shifty:

Ryan:

Paramount:

PSPiso:

AznDrgn:

Songki:

Scrcrw:

Haze:
1. Shifty Because, composition is nice and i like dark themed sigs, it got a wow factor

2. Energy Nicely made, though, lacks a wow factor but is worth 2nd place and i think he should remove tht random grey thingy in upper right corner

3. Ryan he should work on lighting, this sig also lacks a wow factor.

if ryan wouldnt had entered i would choose paramount for 3rd place.

Nobody esle is worth votes.
BSG. Execution, details, focus.
Scrcrw Details, Color use, eye pleasing.
Ryan Fits theme, simple yet emotional.
Ryan-good execution, fits the theme perfectly
Kyle- Greet tag and concept, though lacks the theme which is why i prefer ryans
BSG-Simple, effective, tasty depth
1. Ryan
[Reason]:Fits the theme, depth ad lighting are nice. Simple and effective execution.

2: Shift:
[Reason]:Original concept, but overcontrated in areas. Fits theme.

3: Haze:
[Reason]: Though not the best up there, I feel it fit all aspects of the theme perfectly.
I think it could have been composed better, but still keeping to theme is important.
Otherwise I wouldn't have removed my own entry,
And Energy would have had a 2nd/3rd slot for beasty compo.
1) shifty: It fits the theme and it's also a great photo manip IMO. The lava effects are really put together nicely.

2) Rick93: It fits the theme nicely and, I give him props if he drew that by hand.

3) 420Sabotuer: Although I like photo manips like this one, it deserves third because it is pretty empty and plain. It is well put together but, it's lacking something of interest.
1-bsg, i like his depth and the simplicity
2-ryan, i like the quality and the dark stuff seems like something evil thats consuming her
3-kyle, compared to whats left i thought his was the most best fitting
Shift - I can see where he wanted to go, and that deserves 1st.
Haze - I think this one fits the theme better than any of them, and I love the text.
Songki - I love the effects and the colors, and I'm ignoring the text because I have a feeling you put that there as a piece of crap on purpose.
Shifty: Great and outstanding colours, great concept, good execution
Ryan: Stands out, good use of effects but the scattered dots are dodgy..
Flash: It's got decent depth, nice size and colour, but a bit too blurry.
EnergyK: Sweet ass scene. If you know about Star Wars you'd know that this fits the theme

Ryan: Captured the emotions well and created a good atmosphere

Scrcrw: Sweet fractal use and the red lips were a nice touch.
Posts 110 of 10 · Page 1 of 1
This thread is closed for replies.

Similar Threads

Tags for this Thread

None

Need help?